Owners with poor claims records face double-digit hull and machinery hikes

Shipowners can expect hull and machinery (H&M) insurance to continue to get more expensive.

This year is likely to see premiums increase between 5% and 10% in London and a more moderate 4% in the Nordic market, according to active underwriters and brokers.

However, sources stressed those figures were averages. Owners with poor safety records could find themselves paying a lot more or even being refused renewal, with rate changes close to flat for better performers.

There is also an awareness of a recent spate of car carrier incidents, most notably Felicity Ace (IMO: 9293911), and that vessel type is facing close attention, several players said.

Marine as a class is doing better than it has for some time at Lloyd’s, with syndicates last year ending a run of several years of losses and reporting a collective combined ratio of 93.5% at a time when almost all protection and indemnity (P&I) clubs are exceeding the 100% breakeven mark.

The firm tone for H&M seems slightly surprising at first glance, thanks to several new entrants attracted to the market as a result of restored profitability.

The biggest of these has been Clive Washbourn’s marine-focused managing general agent Navium Marine, which wrote more than $200m of income in its first 12 months and which is said to be pricing very competitively.

Washbourn’s former employer Beazley recently attributed a 6% decline in its hull book to the activities of new entrants and some underwriters believe he has been successful in winning over some of his old Beazley clients.

The head of marine at a large London insurer said his company had kept increases this year down to around 5% rather than double-digit territory seen elsewhere, largely by being more selective.

“We have been through pretty strict remediation. We have turfed out business that is constantly making claims, even if they are just small attritionals,” the insurance executive said. “We’re not charging the claims rises, because we are not having the claims. It is a nice position to be in.”

The tactic is justified because there is a cost to managing claims as well as paying them, so if you reduce claims volume, there are efficiency gains to be had. There are takers for the business rejected, but owners in that category can expect to pay more, he added.

A recent client note from broker Gallagher said although hull rates were still hardening, the momentum behind this is now slowing, with most of the increases being sought probably down to a need to keep up with inflation.

Claims inflation in the short to medium term is likely to mirror the general trend towards higher inflation in many economies. In addition, the rising cost of steel, spare parts and labour will increase the cost of repairs.

“The next few months will be an interesting test of the resolve of the market. Owners who have just faced a bruising P&I renewal now need to turn their attention to H&M policies,” Gallagher said. “Many of these policies may have already been subject to successive increases during the past three to four years. Underwriters generally believe technical rating is still short of where it needs to be.”

However, the opportunity – and, in some cases, the pressure from the boardroom – to build bigger hull books may put the brakes on further premium increases for now, Gallagher added.

Global broker Marsh’s head of marine, Marcus Baker, said the first two quarters of the year had seen some moderation in rate rises and with capacity still high, aggressive remarketing by brokers can lead to reductions in pricing.

“For the balance of the year we expect further moderations and opportunities for hull clients, although the business remains tight, so measured responses are likely. Much of what happens at the back end of this year will depend upon the continued demands of capital for positive revenue growth, but tempered by the nervousness around the likely increases in treaty reinsurance cost in January.

“These probable increases are very much connected to the accumulated losses that have manifested themselves in Ukraine and Russia.”

Gard chief underwriting officer, Bjornar Andresen, whose commercially written hull book is one of the world’s largest, confirmed hull rates are also on the up in the Nordic market, albeit at a more moderate pace.

“What we are experiencing since February 20 – which is our year cut-off – is rates coming up by approximately 4%,” Andresen said. “We are seeing no major shifts in our portfolio; we are more or less keeping what we have.”

It is important to look at accounts individually and consider them based on record. Those with the best records can expect a flat renewal, but Gard is getting the premium levels it needs from those with more challenging records.

As for the second half of 2022, Andresen said: “We will see more or less what we have seen for the past few months. There’s more pressure in the sense there’s more capacity in the market and everybody wants a piece of the pie, but how that will affect the renewals, I’m not sure.”

Andresen said Gard had also been derisking, but not more than usually.

“If it’s too expensive to keep an account, we will take action. If [owners] have a really bad record, they will really have to pay up. Certain performance has a price and we have to make that clear to the clients.”

This article first appeared in Lloyd’s List, a sister publication of Insurance Day